Note: The review process for the call Sustainability and resilience will proceed, despite the government's decision to suspend the process for other calls within development research. Read more about the decision
Closed call
19 April - 23 May 2023
Research project grant: Sustainability and resilience
The purpose of the project grant is to give researchers the freedom to formulate their own research concept, method and implementation, and to solve a specific research task within a limited period. This grant is funded jointly by the Swedish Research Council’s and Formas’ research appropriations. The research shall be of particular relevance to the fight against poverty and for sustainable development in least developed countries. A minimum of one researcher from a least developed or lower middle income country shall participate.
Support form: Project support
Subject area: Development Research
Focus: Sustainability and resilience
Applicant: Individual researcher
Participating researchers: A minimum of 1 and up to 6 other researchers shall be invited to join the application. At least one participating researcher shall be active at an HEI or corresponding in a least developed country or a lower middle income country.
Grant period: 1-3 years
Grant amount: Minimum 400 000 SEK per year, maximum 2 000 000 SEK per year
Start of grant period: January 2024
Application period: 19 April 2023 (14.00/2 pm) – 23 May 2023 (14.00/2 pm)
Publication of grant award: No later than the beginning of December 2023
Please note:
- Your application must include either a junior researcher (no more than 7 years after doctoral degree award) active at a Swedish administrating organisation, or you must have applied for funding from an admitted or potential doctoral student or postdoc at a Swedish administrating organisation (see under “Participating researchers” for more information).
- You must explain in your research plan how your stated activity level is suited to the implementation of the research project. Furthermore, we ask you to describe the management of risks or obstacles to the implementation of the research plan.
- As from 2022, there are guidelines for study registration and result reporting for clinical studies funded by the Swedish Research Council. This means that information about the study shall be registered in a public study register, and that a summary of the results shall be published in the register. More information about the guidelines is available here Opens in new window..
- Read here for information on project collaboration with researchers in Russia and Belarus. Opens in new window.
Specific instructions for the call
In addition to reading the call text, you also need to consult our Guide for applicants Opens in new window..
The following requirements must be fulfilled in order for you to be eligible to apply for the grant. We carry out checks and reject applications that do not fulfil the requirements.
Focus
This call is for project grants within development research, with focus on “Sustainability and resilience – Tackling consequences of climate and environmental changes” with relevance to least developed countries.
With this joint call, the Swedish Research Council and the Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning (Formas) wish to make research into sustainability and resilience a focused priority area.
Climate and environmental changes impact seriously on populations in least developed countries. The consequences are serious when extreme weather conditions change, and the loss of biodiversity and other threats against societies, humans and ecosystems increase. Research into resilience and sustainability that contribute to the understanding of these risks and effects and how they can be managed is therefore of the greatest importance. In this context, it is also of central importance that problems and research questions are formulated jointly with participating researcher in the countries in question.
The aims of the call are to:
- strengthen Swedish research within the area of sustainability and resilience in least developed countries, where sustainability and resilience shall be understood in relation to climate and environmental changes from a multidimensional poverty perspective that includes issues such as power and influence, options for choice, security, gender equality and human rights
- contribute to capacity building within research in least developed countries and lower middle income countries
- strengthen the capacity among junior researchers within the research field at Swedish HEIs
- contribute to equal partnerships between researchers in Sweden and researchers in least developed and lower middle income countries.
Applications from all disciplines and subject areas are welcome. The area is multidisciplinary, and concerns understanding of and/or management of consequences in complex systems. The research funded under the call shall be of high scientific quality, and shall be relevant to the problem area stated in the call. The research projects shall therefore relate to sustainability and resilience in relation to climate and environmental changes from a multidimensional poverty perspective that can include issues such as power and influence, options for choice, security, gender equality and human rights. The research may aim either at immediate benefit or at knowledge of potential long-term importance to the aims of the call. It may cover everything from basic to applied research within all scientific disciplines.
The research shall be of particular relevance to least developed countries, that is, be based on phenomena, circumstances and/or challenges that are specific to, or more noticeable in, least developed countries than in other countries. Collaboration and/or other research activities may be conducted also in other countries. The classification of least developed countries follows OECD’s Development Assistance Committee DAC’s list External link, opens in new window. (the column “Least Developed Countries”).
The research projects should also include a plan for communicating the research results to relevant parties and stakeholders.
Researchers who are awarded funds, and participating researchers in least developed and lower middle income countries, within the call are expected to take part in starting and closing seminars. The starting seminar shall aim primarily to inform about the planned research and provide opportunities for the research teams to meet and discuss joint questions, such as experiences of carrying out international research projects, and to share knowledge within the research field in question. The closing seminar is primarily intended as an outward-looking seminar, aimed at disseminating results from the research carried out. One or several research teams awarded funds under the call will be tasked to arrange these seminars. The seminars will be funded jointly by Formas and the Swedish Research Council. The starting seminar will take place during March–April 2024.
Follow-up of our funding of development research
Development research is financed through Swedish development aid funds and is reported to the OECD’s Development Assistance Committee DAC. To enable this, you must state which of the 17 sustainable development goals External link, opens in new window.that is/are relevant for your application. For the same reason, you must also classify your application according to the OECD’s Development Assistance Committee DAC’s policy markers External link, opens in new window.. The classification does not affect the assessment of your application.
Here you can read more about how the Swedish Research Council reports the use of development aid funds External link..
Applicant
The applicant for a project grant must be an individual researcher together with their organisation (a Swedish higher education institution (HEI) or another Swedish organisation that fulfils our criteria for administrating organisations for Swedish Research Council grants Opens in new window.). We must have approved your organisation as an administrating organisation for you to apply. The administrating organisation must sign your application in Prisma no later than 7 calendar days after the deadline for this call.
You shall be the project leader and have scientific responsibility for the project. The time you set aside for the project (your activity level, that is the percentage of a full-time equivalent) must be suited to the task and its implementation throughout the grant period.
You must hold a Swedish doctoral degree or an equivalent foreign degree, awarded no later than the deadline for this call. For applicants with Swedish doctoral degrees, the award date listed in Ladok applies.
You do not have to be employed by the administrating organisation at the time of application, but you must be employed at the start of and throughout the grant period and any further additional availability period. The employment must equal at least 20 per cent of a full-time equivalent.
Number of applications and previous grants
The requirements described in this section only apply to applicants (project leaders).
General information about overlaps between applications and grants
Your application must not cover costs for purposes that are already funded by the Swedish Research Council or any other funding body. Overlaps with other grants or applications may impact on the grant amount you are awarded, or be a reason for us to reject your application.
What grants may I apply for simultaneously from the Swedish Research Council?
You may only submit one application for this grant under this call. You may, however, apply for other project grants, but for another project concept. You may apply simultaneously for the call for international postdoc grant in development research, but if both applications are approved you must choose between the grants. Further information about the grants you may apply for during the same year are shown in on the page Several grants simultaneously Opens in new window..
What requirements apply if I already have a grant from the Swedish Research Council?
There are certain restrictions if you are the project leader of an ongoing grant, that is to say where the grant period (payment period from the Swedish Research Council) overlaps the grant period of the grant the application relates to. Please note that the availability period, that is to say the time during which you have the right to use your grant, is normally longer than the grant period. You can find information about your ongoing grant in the “Approval of terms and conditions” you received from the Swedish Research Council.
If you already have an ongoing grant, then further information about the grants you may apply for are shown in on the page Several grants simultaneously. Opens in new window. Please note that if you are the project leader for an ongoing project grant, this must relate to a different project concept for you to be able to apply.
If you are the project leader for an ongoing research environment grant, you may submit an application under this call, provided that the project grant application is not part of the research environment grant.
Note: If you have been the project leader for previous grants from the Swedish Research Council that have ended, final financial reports for all of these must have been submitted within the permitted time frame in order for you to apply for a new grant. Please contact your administrating organisation if you are unsure whether all your final reports have been submitted.
What applies for applications to or grants from other funding bodies?
If your application to the Swedish Research Council relates to the same project concept as a grant you have already been awarded by, or are applying for to another funding body, please describe this.
Participating researchers
You must include minimum 1 and maximum 6 participating researchers in your application. Participating researchers are other researchers with a doctoral degree or equivalent competence (not doctoral students) whose scientific competence will be crucial for the implementation of the planned research.
A minimum of one researcher from a least developed or lower middle income country shall be invited as international project leader. The international project leader shall have a doctoral degree or corresponding competency.
Your application must include either a junior researcher (no more than 7 years after doctoral degree award) active at a Swedish administrating organisation, or you must have applied for funding for an admitted or potential doctoral student or postdoc at a Swedish administrating organisation.
If the junior researcher is a doctoral student, you shall not invite them as a participating researcher in the application, but instead describe their participation/role in the project in the research plan. You yourself may be the junior researcher in the application.
Both the participating researcher in a least developed or lower middle income country, and the participating junior researcher at a Swedish administrating organisation must have an activity level in the project corresponding to at least 20 per cent of a full-time equivalent.
Participating researchers shall provide the necessary information themselves in Prisma, and upload these to the application. Any further collaborating partners and their roles shall be described in the research plan (please see instructions under “Research plan” below).
Costs and grant amounts
You can apply for a grant for all types of project-related costs, such as
- salaries (including your own salary), however no more than corresponding to the person’s activity level in the project
- premises
- running costs (such as consumables, travel including stays at research facilities, publication costs and minor equipment)
- depreciation costs.
The grant amount includes cover of indirect costs as a percentage of the direct costs, according to the model used by your administrating organisation. Grants must not be used for scholarships. If a doctoral student participates, project funds may not be paid out as salary during teaching or other departmental duties. The grant must be used in accordance with the OECD’s Development Assistance Committee DAC’s guidelines for what can be classified as aid.
The minimum amount you may apply for is 400 000 SEK per year, including indirect costs. The maximum amount you may apply for is 2 000 000 SEK per year.
Grant period
You may apply for a grant for a minimum of 1 year and a maximum of 3 years, starting in January 2024. The first payment will be made during January 2024 at the earliest.
Please refer to the application form in Prisma in parallel with reading the instructions below, which describe the call-specific content of the application. More information on what to do in practical terms is available in our Guide for applicants Opens in new window..
Language
International experts are involved in the scientific assessment of the applications. To ensure fair and equitable assessment and efficient processing, please therefore complete your application in English, apart from the popular science description, which you must write in Swedish.
Sections of the application
The application form includes the following tabs:
- Descriptive information
- Research description
- Budget and research resources
- Publications
- Administrating organisation
- Participants
- CV
The information we request under each tab is described below.
Descriptive information
Abstract
In the abstract, please describe in brief the following:
- What is to be done: purpose and aims
- How the research will be carried out: project organisation, time plan and scientific methods
- What is important about the planned research
The abstract shall provide a summary picture of the purpose and implementation of the research. Please use wording to ensure persons with another subject specialisation can understand the information.
The description may cover a maximum of 1 500 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately one third of an A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Popular science description
Describe the planned research in such a way that a person who is not a researcher can understand it. Do this by answering the following questions:
- What is the research about?
- Why is it important to research this?
- In what way may the new knowledge be important?
The popular science description is important when we inform about the research funded by the Swedish Research Council.
The text must be in Swedish and may cover a maximum of 2 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately half an A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Other applications or grants
Describe the relationship between the different projects if
- you are applying for or intend to apply for other grants from the Swedish Research Council
- you are receiving an ongoing grant from the Swedish Research Council with a grant period that wholly or partly overlaps with the grant you are now applying for
- there are applications or grants relating to the same project concept/purpose from the Swedish Research Council or other funding bodies (from you or another researcher).
In all cases, you should also justify why you are submitting one or several further applications. If there are no other applications or grants, please state so.
The description may cover a maximum of 2 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately half an A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Relevant countries
State the countries that the project is relevant for. The information is used for reporting and statistical purposes.
Country of operation – international participating researchers
List the 1–3 countries where the international project leader (and any other international participating researchers) is active.
Participating junior researchers
State the category of junior researchers who are participating in the project.
Sustainable development goals
State which of the 17 sustainable development goals (according to Agenda 2030) your project is linked to in particular, or if none of them is relevant. Further information is available under the heading “Follow-up of our funding of development research” at the beginning of the call text.
Policy markers OpenAid
State to what extent your project focuses on each policy marker area. You can find a link to a description of the policy markers under the heading “Follow-up of our funding of development research” at the beginning of the call text.
Research description
Ethical aspects
Legal and formal requirements
State whether the research covers the handling of personal data, or experiments on animals and/or studies involving humans.
If the research covers any of the above, you must also describe/state the approvals and permits your research project requires, and how you plan to obtain these. Describe any other permits that affect your application, such as whether parts of the research will be done in a country other than Sweden. If no approvals or permits are needed, please state so.
The description may cover a maximum of 2 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately half an A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Further information is available on the page Conducting ethical research Opens in new window..
Ethical considerations
Reflect on the ethical issues that may arise for your project, and describe these. You must also describe how you plan to address ethical dilemmas that may arise. Please justify why the research should be carried out against the background of the ethical issues you have identified. Examples of issues to reflect on:
- How do your research questions and expected results measure up in relation to the ethical issues?
- What (direct) risks (physical, mental, or integrity) will research persons or animals be exposed to?
- What long-term risks may arise from the research? Is there any risk that the research may be used in a way that is detrimental to animals, nature/the environment, or society (whole or parts of the same) in other respects?
- Is the research expected to contribute to other values over and above the knowledge gain? If so, to whom?
- How do you weigh up the risks (in particular short-term risks) against the value (which is often more long-term) of the research?
If no ethical issues are raised, please justify this. The description may cover a maximum of 4 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately one A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Sex and gender perspectives
Please state whether sex and gender perspectives are applicable in your planned research, and justify your decision. Please note that we are not asking for information about the composition of the research team (men/women). Read more about sex and gender perspectives in research content Opens in new window..
The following applies:
- If you answer “Yes”: Please justify your answer, and describe also how you take account of sex and gender perspectives in the research plan. If you have stated that sex and gender perspectives are applicable, but still choose not to include them in your research plan, you will need to justify this here.
- If you answer “No”: Please justify your answer.
The justification may cover a maximum of 4 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately one A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Research plan
The research plan shall be forward-looking and consist of a brief but complete description of the research task. It may cover a maximum of 10 page-numbered A4 pages in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing and 2.5 cm margins, including references and any images.
The research plan must include the following headings and information, listed in the following order:
- Purpose and aims: State the overall purpose and specific aims of the research project.
- State-of-the-art: Summarise briefly the current research frontier within the field or area covered by the project. State key references.
- Significance and scientific novelty: Describe briefly how the project relates to previous research within the area, and the impact the project may have in the short and long term. Describe also how the project moves forward or innovates the current research frontier.
- Preliminary and previous results: Describe briefly your own previous research and pilot studies within the research area that make it probable that the project will be feasible. If no preliminary results exist, please state this. State also whether the project continues to build on research and scientific results from a grant awarded previously by the Swedish Research Council.
- Project description: Describe the project design under the following headings:
- Theory and method: Describe the underlying theory and the methods to be applied in order to reach the project goal.
- Time plan and implementation: Describe summarily the time plan for the project during the grant period, and how the project will be implemented. Describe also any crucial risks or obstacles that may impact on the implementation, and your plan for managing these.
- Project organisation: Clarify how you and the participating researchers will contribute to the implementation of the project. Explain in particular how the time allocated by you (that is, your activity level) as project leader is suitable for the task, including the relationship with your other research undertakings. Describe and explain the competences and roles of the participating researchers in the project, and also other key persons (including any doctoral students) who are important for the implementation of the project.
- Security situation in collaboration country: If you are planning to carry out research activities or fieldwork in countries or regions that the Swedish Ministry for Foreign Affairs is advising against travelling to (including work travel), please describe how you are planning your research visit to and work in the country in view of the security situation. Read more about the countries the Swedish Ministry for Foreign Affairs is advising against travelling to on the website of the Swedish Government Offices (in Swedish). External link, opens in new window.
- Dissemination of results: Describe how you plan to communicate the results of the research to relevant parties and stakeholders to promote the impact of the research.
Provide the following information also. If a heading is not relevant to your application, please state this under the heading.
- Equipment: Describe the basic equipment you and your team have at your disposal for the project.
- Need for research infrastructure: Specify the project’s need for international and national research infrastructure. If you choose to use other infrastructure than those supported by the Swedish Research Council Opens in new window., and that are thereby open to all, you must justify this (also applies to local research infrastructure).
- International and national collaboration: Describe your own and the team’s collaboration with foreign and Swedish researchers and research teams. State whether you contribute to or refer to international collaboration in your research.
- Independent line of research: If you are working or will be working in a larger group, please clarify how your project relates to the other projects in the group. If you are (continuing) working in the same team as your doctoral or postdoc supervisor, or if you are continuing a project that wholly or partly started during your doctoral or postdoc studies, you must also describe the relationship between your project and the research of your former supervisor.
Relevance
Research projects in development research shall be of particular relevance to the fight against poverty and for sustainable development in least developed countries (for further information, please see under the heading “Focus” above). Therefore, describe clearly
- how the research project and its questions are based on phenomena and challenges relating to poverty/the fight against poverty and for sustainable development, and how poverty and other sustainability challenges depend on each other
- why and how the research is particularly relevant to the fight against poverty and for sustainable development in least developed countries and for people living in poverty
- how the project can contribute new knowledge with the potential to contribute to improving conditions for people living in poverty and under oppression and to promote sustainable development specifically in least developed countries and regions.
Present possible ways and means for your research to have impact and/or be put to use, in the short or long term, and formulate these as possible “pathways to impact” for your research. Describe also whether the questions are relevant for least developed countries other than that/those included in the study.
The description may cover a maximum of 4 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately one A4 page in Arial, font size 11.
Budget and research resources
Project personnel
State the activity level (per cent of a full-time equivalent) of all personnel active within the project, that is, you, any other researchers, doctoral students and other personnel. Please also state the salary you are applying for, for yourself and/or other personnel active within the project, both as a percentage of a full-time salary and as actual annual amounts (including social security contributions). Please state the amounts in Swedish krona, rounded to the nearest 1 000 SEK.
Other costs
Describe any other costs of the project (premises costs, running costs and depreciation costs). Please state the amounts in Swedish krona, rounded to the nearest 1 000 SEK.
You may include depreciation costs for equipment to be used in the project, provided that
- the equipment has an economic life of at least three years
- the equipment has an acquisition value above a certain amount
- the need cannot be satisfied through use of national or international infrastructure supported by the Swedish Research Council and thereby open to all.
You may only include the proportion of depreciation costs that corresponds to the use of the equipment in the proposed project, and you may not include depreciation costs for equipment that is wholly funded by other grants. Please contact your administrating organisation for information about what is included in local research infrastructure, acquisition values or how to calculate depreciation costs.
Total cost of the project
Prisma will automatically add up your budget items in a table. The total amount you are applying for shall also include indirect costs. You will have to add these to the table yourself. Here you can also add any additional costs that the project entails (for which you are not seeking funding under this call).
Indirect costs follow the model that your administrating organisation uses. Please contact your administrating organisation if you have any questions about what constitutes indirect and direct costs.
Justification of the budget applied for
Justify briefly each cost applied for in your budget. The description may cover a maximum of 4 000 characters including blank spaces. This is approximately one A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing.
Other funding
Please state your or any other researcher’s funding for the project over and above what is applied for in this application. Please state the amounts in Swedish krona, rounded to the nearest 1 000 SEK.
Publications
Applicant’s publication list
Please attach your publication list drawn up according to the headings and information below. The list may cover a maximum of 5 page-numbered A4 pages in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing and 2.5 cm margins.
Sort the publications under each heading in reverse chronological order, so that the latest publication is at the top of the list. Please only include articles or equivalent that are published or accepted for publication at the time of applying. The author name order shall be identical to that of the published work. The application cannot be supplemented with publications after the deadline for the call.
1. Selection of publications: List the 10 publications of greatest importance to your application. Describe how you contributed to each publication, and its relevance to the research project described (maximum 4 lines per publication). Highlight your name in bold in the author list.
2. Relevant publications from 2015–2023: In this part, the publications listed under Item 1 shall also be included if they have been published during the period in question. Sort the publications, with your name highlighted in bold in the author list, under each heading (publication type) in the following order:
- Peer-reviewed original articles
- Peer-reviewed conference contributions, the results of which are not included in other publications
- Peer-reviewed edited volumes
- Research review articles
- Peer-reviewed books and book chapters
- Other publications including popular science books/presentations
Participating researchers’ publication lists
Attach all participating researchers’ publication lists joined up into one file. The list for each researcher shall include the 10 publications that are the most relevant to the research described, and shall cover a maximum of 1 A4 page in Arial, font size 11, single line spacing and 2.5 cm margins. The name of the researcher in question shall be highlighted in bold and also be included in the page header of each list.
Please only include articles or equivalent that are published or accepted for publication at the time of applying. The author name order shall be identical to that of the published work. The application cannot be supplemented with publications after the deadline for the call.
The publications shall be of the types: Peer-reviewed original articles, conference contributions, edited volumes, research review articles, books and book chapters, and other publications including popular science books/presentations.
Administrating organisation
Please state the administrating organisation and project site.
Participants
Under this tab, you shall invite the participating researchers and any participating administrators to your application.
CV
Under this tab, please upload your relevant CV information from your personal account in Prisma. Participating researchers must upload their own CV information to the application.
The following information (where available) must always be included in each CV:
- Education: First, second and third cycle higher education and specialist degrees.
- Work: Current employment (including employment form) and longer relevant employment held, postdoctoral visits (also included as employment if relevant), research exchanges relevant to the research described and any longer interruptions in the research that have impacted on your opportunity to gain merit as a researcher.
- Merits and awards: Docentship/associate professorship, supervisees (postdoctoral and doctoral students; state the number of persons in each category and list the names of the up to 10 most relevant to you), up to 10 of your most relevant grants awarded in competition, up to 10 of your most relevant prizes and awards, and up to 20 other merits relevant to the application.
- Intellectual property rights: For example, patents and open access computer programs developed by you; state up to 10 of your most relevant.
Scientific quality is the fundamental criterion when the Swedish Research Council allocates grants to research. Your application is evaluated in competition with the other applications on the basis of the following evaluation criteria.
Evaluation process
Your application for Research project grant in Sustainability and resilience is evaluated by a broad, specialised subject review panel where the members are Swedish and international researchers.
At least three members review and grade your application individually. If the needed, the reviews of the panel members will be complemented with an assessment from an external reviewer with specialised expertise in the subject of the application. The entire review panel (not including any external reviewers) then meets at a review panel meeting to discuss and prioritise the applications, and finally to make a proposal for a decision to the Committee for Development Research.
Review panel Opens in new window.
In order to enable more in-depth discussions of applications of higher quality that have a reasonable chance of being funded, the applications that received the lowest grades from the panel members are not discussed in detail at the review panel meeting. Following the grant decision, all applications receive a final statement that includes the review panel’s grading of the application. The applications that have been discussed in more detail at the panel meeting receive an individual final statement which, in addition to the grades, also contains a summary of the review panel’s discussion and joint assessment of the scientific quality of the application.
Evaluation criteria and guiding questions
The evaluation of the scientific quality of your application is made based on four basic criteria (Scientific quality of the proposed research, Novelty and originality, Merits of the applicant, Feasibility). The purpose of using several components is to achieve a multi-faceted evaluation. The criteria are assessed on a seven-grade scale, except for feasibility, which is assessed on a three-grade scale.
In addition to the basic criteria, your application is also evaluated using an additional criterion (Relevance for the call) on a seven-grade scale.
For each criterion, there are guiding questions to support the panel members’ evaluation of your application. These can also function as guidance for you when you write your application.
Scientific quality of the proposed research (1–7)
Guiding questions:
- To what extent are the design of the project and its questions of the highest scientific quality?
- To what extent is the project description sufficiently clear and systematic, for example in its definition of the research problem, its theoretical basis, and the summary of previous results within the research area?
- To what extent is the proposed research design suitable for achieving the aims of the project?
- To what extent are the methods for any data collection and analysis well described and suitable?
- Are the ethical considerations for the proposed project properly described and addressed? Does the applicant adequately consider risk/value/suffering for humans, animals and nature?
- Has the applicant in a satisfactory manner described the possible importance of sex and/or gender for the research project? If not, is there a clear description to why?
- If sex and gender is described as relevant to the research project, has the applicant considered sex and gender in the study design and description of the proposed work, for instance as part of preliminary data, the choice of samples or study population, or data analyses?
Novelty and originality (1–7)
Guiding questions:
- To what extent does the project extend or challenge current understanding, opinion or practice in its field? (For example, novel concepts or theories, new directions for research and advancement of the field.)
- To what extent does the proposed project define new, compelling scientific questions within its scientific area?
- To what extent does the project include use of novel technologies/methodologies, or innovative application of existing methodologies/technologies in a novel way or context?
- To what extent does the project propose a line of research with clear progression and novelty in relation to previous research in the field?
- In what novel way does the proposed project have potential for scientific and/or societal impact in least developed countries?
Merits of the applicant (1–7)
Guiding questions:
- To what extent does the research team have sufficient experience and expertise in the research area(s) of the proposed project?
- In relation to research area and career age: Of what merits are the project participants’ scientific production (e.g. publications, supervisor experience, external funding, research collaborations)? To what extent do these merits show a distinct and independent line of research?
- To what extent is there ability to successfully disseminate research findings to relevant parties and stakeholders?
- To what extent does the applicant have a sufficient scientific network for implementing the proposed project?
Feasibility (1–3)
Guiding questions:
- Is the general design, including time schedule, optimal for implementing the proposed project?
- Does the project include the availability and accessibility of personnel with relevant skills? (Also taking into consideration the activity level.)
- Is the environment suitable for carrying out the proposed research, considering e.g. equipment, facilities/infrastructures and other necessary resources and support?
- Are the proposed research methods, infrastructures, experiments and fieldwork appropriate for the implementation of the project?
- Does the applicant adequately consider relevant legal and formal requirements for the proposed research, such as ethical permits and guidelines?
- How is the balance between the project´s feasibility and risks and its potential gains? (high risk/high gain)
Relevance for the call (1-7)
Relevance is a key criterion for assessment of development research. It is assessed separately from scientific quality and is included in the overall grade. Research projects within development research shall have particular relevance to the fight against poverty and for sustainable development in least developed countries.
Guiding questions:
- Does the research clearly relate to the theme of the call: sustainability and resilience - tackling consequences of climate and environmental changes?
- Is the research clearly based in questions relating to poverty/the fight against poverty and sustainable development in least developed countries?
- Is it described how poverty and other sustainability challenges depend on each other?
- Does the research concern conditions and challenges that are specific, or of particular importance, to least developed countries?
- Does the research have the potential to contribute to improving conditions for people living in poverty and under oppression in least developed countries specifically?
- Does the research also have the potential to contribute to sustainable development in these least developed countries?
- Is there a clearly described idea about, and description of, pathways-to-impact?
- Are the research questions relevant to least developed countries other than the specific country/countries where the study takes place?
Overall grade (1–7)
The above subsidiary criteria are weighed together into an overall grade, which reflects the review panel’s joint evaluation of the application’s scientific quality.